• RSS Queering the Church

    • The Celibacy Wars: A Reason for Hope? August 9, 2014
      Quite suddenly, my news feeds are full of stories and opinion pieces on celibacy and gay Christians, from the evangelical Christian Charisma News and the like on the one hand, to the gay Advocate on the other. On the religious…Read more →
      Terence Weldon
    • Pope Francis: The Family as a “Centre of Love” – and Inclusion. August 8, 2014
      In a message to the First Latin American Congress on the Pastoral Care of the Family in Panama, Pope Francis’ thoughts on the nature of family deserve close attention by LGBT Catholics. What is the family? Beyond its more pressing problems…Read more →
      Terence Weldon
  • RSS Spirit of a Liberal

    • Gay Games Symposium July 21, 2014
      I am pleased and honored that the UCC has asked me to moderate a symposium during the games entitled Queer Christians: Celebrating the Past, Shaping the Future. [[ This is a content summary only. Visit my website for full links, other content, and more! ]]
      Obie Holmen
    • Email sent to my followers June 27, 2014
      Whew! It's time to catch my breath. Since the release of Queer Clergy in February, I've been on the road ... Minnesota, Wisconsin, Illinois, and California. I have been the guest of book clubs, adult forums, LGBT reconciling groups, the Pacific School of Religion, and I've been a guest preacher (always a treat for an old lawyer). I've mad […]
      Obie Holmen
  • RSS There Will be Bread

    • Where Are You? October 26, 2011
      Greetings to all others who grace these pages! Thank you for stopping by. If you still have a reader pointed here, this blog no longer publishes in this location, but can be found at this new link. Please subscribe to the new feed, get the new blog via email or read us by liking us on Facebook or by following me on Twitter.If you want more, please feel free […]
      noreply@blogger.com (Fran)
  • RSS The Wild Reed

    • Photo of the Day August 20, 2014
      See also the previous Wild Reed posts:Photo of the Day – April 17, 2014Photo of the Day – August 28, 2013Photo of the Day – July 25, 2012Photo of the Day – November 17, 2011Photo of the Day – July 17, 2011Photo of the Day – December 19, 2010Pacific SkiesImage: Michael J. Bayly.
      noreply@blogger.com (Michael J. Bayly)
    • Quote of the Day August 18, 2014
      Without really meaning to, Kate Bush has stood for many things. She has stood for English pop as a discrete idiom, sheared free of its American roots. She has stood firmly for artistic independence in the face of corporate will, by standing up to record-company bosses and by forming her own management and publishing companies at an age most of us are prepare […]
      noreply@blogger.com (Michael J. Bayly)
  • RSS Bilgrimage

    • Quote for Day: "Tear Gas Is an Abortifacient. Why Won't the Anti-Abortion Movement Oppose It?" August 20, 2014
      Michelle Goldberg at The Nation today:Tear gas is an abortifacient. Why won’t the anti-abortion movement oppose it?Why, indeed? Why are many people who call themselves staunch pro-lifers, and who are willing to go to any length to oppose health insurance coverage for women that includes the morning-after pill — a contraceptive — completely silent about the u […]
      noreply@blogger.com (William D. Lindsey)
    • Bibles, Churches, Gays, Religion: Bilgrimage Readers Continue an Important Discussion August 20, 2014
      Recently, I responded to a question asked by a thoughtful reader of this blog (Bob/tinywriting) about how one determines when Christian groups have gone completely off-track as they appeal to the Jewish and Christian scriptures to ground their claim that they authentically represent the message of Christ. I also later added to that initial discussion several […]
      noreply@blogger.com (William D. Lindsey)
  • RSS Enlightened Catholicism

  • RSS Far From Rome

    • the way ahead March 23, 2013
      My current blog is called the way ahead.
      noreply@blogger.com (PrickliestPear)
  • RSS The Gay Mystic

    • The travails of young love July 30, 2014
      On a bit of a hiatus from blogging for the summer as I recollect my spirit, but I may have some reflections to share this weekend about the difficulties of young love. Been listening to tales of heartbreak from some of my young students. And young River Viiperi has broken from his partner of two years, Paris Hilton, so these must be difficult days for him as […]
      noreply@blogger.com (Jayden Cameron )
    • Papa Francesco does it again July 14, 2014
      Well, the whole world - or at least the semi Christian world - is all a flutter over yet another freewheeling interview of Pope Francis conducted by acknowledged atheist and La Republica journalist Eduardo Scalfari. Before the ink had barely dried, Father Lombardi of The Vatican Press Office was already huffing out his damage control , assuring us that Scalf […]
      noreply@blogger.com (Jayden Cameron )
  • RSS The Jesus Manifesto

    • プロミスとアコムならどっちで借りるべきか? August 2, 2014
      借り入れまでの審査時間の短さで、キャッシング先を消費者金融にしようと決めた方もどこの消費者金融がよいのかで困っていませんか?消費者金融でもトップといってもよいプロミスとアコム、借りるならどっちを選ぶとよいのでしょうか。プロミスの最大の特徴は、金利の低さでしょう。プロミスの金利幅は、4.5%~17.8%の実質年率となっています。比較してアコムの金利幅は4.7%~18.0%となっています。(アコムカードローンでの金利となり、アコムクレジットカードでのキャッシング金利は違ってきます。)また、無利息サービスもプロミスは、プロミスポイントサービスにお申込された方が対象に行われています。一方のアコムでは、無利息は期間限定のサービスとなっています。いずれも無利息になるためには条件があるのですが、プロミスではポイントサービスへ […]
  • RSS John McNeill: Spiritual Transformations

  • RSS Perspective

    • And more on Hans Urs von Balthasar August 19, 2014
      After seeing Karen Kilby's talk in my previous post, I was intrigued to see that Fr. Baron had a couple of video talks on von Balthasar as well. Usually I find Fr. Baron too conservative, but his take on the Swiss Jesuit was interesting ... I didn't know, for instance, that he was a fan of Mozart :) ...
      noreply@blogger.com (crystal)

The Borking of Herman Cain and Father Thomas Weinandy (A Headline You Never Thought You’d Read)

Here’s a blast from the past, a word you probably thought you’d never need to look up again: “borking.”  After conservative journalist Mona Charen published an article yesterday in the National Review  suggesting that liberals are borking poor Herman Cain, the word is now plastered once again all over American media websites.    Mind you, though Charen has impeccable right-wing credentials (she was, after all, a speechwriter for Nancy Reagan), her essay concludes that Cain may be playing the unfair character-assassination angle to avoid telling the truth about what went on between him and former employees who claim Cain sexually harassed them.

Even so, borking: it’s back.  Back in the news.  Big-time.  And the context in which it’s appearing in the news is fascinating to me because of its cultural implications.  There are already reports that the breaking of the story about Cain’s troubles due to alleged sexual harassment has actually benefited his campaign financially.  Donations began pouring in immediately after the sexual harassment story hit the news, and as Evan McMorris-Santoro and Jillian Rayfield report at Talking Points Memo today, right-wing commentators are using the Cain story as an occasion to dust off old charges that good men are under attack by bad women in a culture of feminism gone mad.

They’re even–amazingly–reviving the Clarence Thomas story as an illustration of how bad women try to bork good men.  Just because.  Because that’s what bad women do.  And so Cain is evidently now benefiting from his claim that he’s being unfairly pilloried by the press because there’s considerable sympathy among many American males for any man, particularly a powerful one, who appears to be under attack from any nasty feminist-type woman and the “liberal” media that give such women voices.

Given this very recent cultural backdrop to the revival of interest in the term “borking,” and given the heavy macho-heterosexist overtones of the term, I’m intrigued to see Commonweal editor Matthew Boudway and Commonweal regular Deacon Jim Pauwels trying to argue in this current thread at the Commonweal blog site that poor Father Thomas Weinandy of the U.S. Catholic Bishops Conference’s Committee on Doctrine is being borked.  The Committee on Doctrine is the USCCB body that has raised grave questions about the theological integrity of Sister Elizabeth Johnson’s book She Who Is (and, implicitly, about Johnson’s own personal and academic integrity, since attacks on the scholarship of a bona fide scholar inevitably impinge on the character of the scholar whose work is being attacked).

As the posting by Grant Gallicho to which the discussion of Weinandy-borking is appended notes, the chair of the Committee on Doctrine, Cardinal Donald Wuerl, under whom Weinandy serves, has just released a statement saying that Sr. Elizabeth Johnson refused to meet with the Committee on Doctrine after it apprised her of the errors of her book.  That claim appears to be, to put it mildly, untrue.  As Joshua McElwee reports at National Catholic Reporter, Johnson flatly refutes the cardinal’s claim that she refused to meet with his committee, and has a detailed timeline showing precisely how and when she and the committee communicated with each other–a claim substantiated by the documentary timeline that accompanies Gallicho’s posting.

And so I’m interested in the claim that poor Fr. Weinandy is now being borked–and, by implication, that his USCCB superior Wuerl is also being treated unfairly in the ongoing exchange at various Catholic websites about what’s been done to Sr. Elizabeth Johnson.  The OED defines borking as “to defame or vilify (a person) systematically, esp. in the mass media, usually with the aim of preventing his or her appointment to public office; to obstruct or thwart (a person) in this way.”

And as I read that definition and think about it in light of Boudway and Pauwels’ claim that Weinandy is being borked, the following questions occur to me:

1. On the face of it, isn’t it far more accurate to call what the USCCB has done to Sr. Elizabeth Johnson a borking?  If to bork someone is to defame or vilify her systematically in a highly public way, with the aim of obstructing and thwarting that person’s career and influence, it seems to me, prima facie, that it’s far easier to make a strong case for the borking of Elizabeth Johnson than for the borking of Thomas Weinandy (or Donald Wuerl).

2. And as long as we’re going to dust off this antiquated term, what about what Wuerl and his penultimate predecessor in the see of Washington, D.C., Cardinal Hickey, did to their fellow bishop Archbishop Raymond Hunthausen right around the same time Robert Bork was being borked?   Remember that blast from the past?  Hunthausen made pastoral overtures to the gay and lesbian community (though his really grievous sin may have been his public resistance to the arms race and his resistance to paying taxes to build nuclear warheads), and Rome pounced.  Cardinal Ratzinger sent Hickey to do an investigation of Hunthausen akin to the one Archbishop Chaput was just commissioned to do of Bishop William Morris in Australia.

And the upshot was that Wuerl was placed in Hunthausen’s diocese as an auxiliary bishop given the right to usurp Hunthausen’s own episcopal power in his own diocese–an unheard-of slap in the face in the Catholic system, which normally jealously safeguards the absolute right of a bishop to be a little king in his own diocesan domain.

The ultimate effects of all this behavior on Hunthausen, his reputation, and his career, certainly look to me like what happens when someone is borked.  Public, official vilification, character assassination, and defamation designed to besmirch the image of someone in power, so that he never wields power again . . . .  Hunthausen was eventually more or less roughly shunted into the shadows, where he has lived ever since.  While Wuerl has gone on to a brilliant career as the cardinal archbishop of a major American see, where he exerts great power in the nation’s political center and spends what time he has left over from the tiring demands of powermongering commissioning investigations of the incorrect teachings of theologians like Sr. Elizabeth Johnson.

3. And come to think of it, have you ever actually heard claims that a woman is being borked?  Robert Bork, the original borkee, was a powerful man.  Herman Cain, we’re now being told, was borked.  Do a google search linking the terms “Clarence Thomas” and “bork,” and you’ll come up with a wealth of hits claiming that poor Clarence Thomas has been borked over and over again.

But I’m not aware of similar cases in which there’s a large hue and cry about the borking of women.  Of Elizabeth Johnson, for instance.  Or of Anita Hill, whose testimony against Thomas convinced many of us that she was speaking the truth and Thomas was spectacularly evading the truth–though he got himself confirmed as a Supreme Court justice despite this borking.

There’s not a verb for what was done to Anita Hill in those hearings, is there?  Robert Bork (and Thomas and Cain and now Weinandy/Wuerl) were borked.  But Anita Hill wasn’t hilled.  We don’t seem to have any pithy, testosterone-laden, one-syllable verbs to describe the public, ritual humiliation of a woman, designed to ruin her reputation forever, and drive her decisively from the circles of power.

4. And so whose interests, specifically, are Boudway and Pauwels defending in arguing that poor Thomas Weinandy is being borked in the case of Sr. Elizabeth Johnson?  Charges about borking seem to arise quite specifically from a heterosexist-male social location, and to be pitched very strongly in the direction of defending heterosexual males from accusations made against them by women.  These charges presuppose a heterosexist-male social location even when women make them.  There are scores of women in conservative political and religious circles who actively promote a macho-heterosexist worldview premised on heterosexual male entitlement.

Charges about borking are pitched in the direction of defending heterosexual males from accusations made against them by women.   Or by gay men, since the Commonweal thread in which Boudway and Pauwels maintain that poor Fr. Weinandy is being borked begins with a contribution by Francis DeBernardo of New Ways Ministry,  a Catholic ministry that calls for pastoral outreach to those who are gay and lesbian.  And, in fact, DeBarnardo tells a story very similar to that now being told by Sr. Elizabeth Johnson, about his group’s dealings with Weinandy.

And so it’s doubly interesting that Boudway and Pauwels choose to leap to Weinandy’s defense in a thread that begins with the testimony of a man who heads a Catholic ministry of compassionate outreach to those who are gay.  It’s almost as if some of the key folks who power the Commonweal enterprise want to make the testimony of gay Catholics and those in solidarity with gay Catholics appear completely beside the point–to bork that testimony so that it has no hearing in any circles of power that shape the agenda of American Catholicism, and so that it’s as if the walls have spoken when an openly gay voice speaks in these circles.  As usually happens when the walls speak, those of us doing power business simply carry on with our power business as if no one has spoken at all.

While never avowing the heterosexual male power and privilege we’re defending as we bork our brothers and sisters who happen to be gay by pretending that their testimony is not worth hearing, since it proceeds from a polluted source.  Or as if they haven’t spoken at all, once they’ve provided their testimony . . . .

Am I right?  That’s how it appears to me, and these are some questions I feel inclined to ask on this day of All Souls, which always strikes me as a powerful salient liturgical reminder of the importance of every voice in the enterprise called Catholicism, which is, I have always understood, about inviting everyone inside.

Cross-posted from Bilgrimage, 2 November 2011.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 143 other followers

%d bloggers like this: